Streetlight's is better.
Because it's not as rough as the Catch-22 version. And since it's ska and not punk the roughness doesn't really matter.
SM's versions of Dear Sergio, Day In Day Out and Kristina are far better than the originals.
And the snare sounds awesome, usually I hate snare on ska albums because it doesn't sound like a snare it sounds like a popcorn popping or something.
