You’ll notice if you pay attention to the cuts from stage shots to audience shots. Sometimes the band members will change positions or be doing vastly different actions; I thought maybe the band was re-playing the songs live. But the lighting is also vastly different, and for some songs, so poor on the stage that it’s clear it wasn’t shot during a live show.
There’s a dead giveaway in the banter before She Has a Girlfriend now; the lighting sucks, and Dan and John are literally just standing dead in the background, which they would never be doing live…and aren’t when it cuts to the audience.
.
